Poland judges strip Constitutional Tribunal president Bogdan Święczkowski of immunity

Analysis: Europe — 20 November 2026

Government-backed judges strip Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal president of immunity

An assembly of judges convened by Anna Korwin-Piotrowska on 17 November stripped Constitutional Tribunal president Bogdan Święczkowski of immunity in four cases and deputy Bartłomiej Sochański in one, PAP reported; the text went on the tribunal website on 18 November. Prosecutors under Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek can now file charges. The assembly refused consent for Święczkowski’s arrest. The European Court of Human Rights rejected an interim halt the same day. Supreme Court head Zbigniew Kapiński said on 18 November that the eight government-backed judges’ acts have no legal force. UnHerd’s Thomas Fazi, on 20 November, calls the standoff an institutional civil war.

The crisis opened on 30 October, when Korwin-Piotrowska — elected by Donald Tusk’s Sejm majority but not sworn in by President Karol Nawrocki — suspended the PiS-era leadership as riot police ringed the building. Nawrocki turned his plane back from Senegal and forced his way in. The Supreme Court overturned the suspensions on 10 November; police still blocked re-entry. Tusk says he is restoring the rule of law after PiS “captured” the 15-member court. PiS calls it a coup. Nawrocki refused five of this year’s new oaths; the Commission has backed parliament’s power to appoint.

Fact and argument now diverge. The Tribunal is the last-instance body on whether EU law overrides the Polish constitution. The ECJ held in December 2025 that the Tribunal violated EU law by rejecting primacy. Fazi’s analysis is that Brussels and Tusk mean “rule of Brussels’s law,” and that taking the court now would constrain a possible Right return in 2027. Legal scholars who criticised PiS have said Korwin-Piotrowska’s suspension lacked a constitutional basis. The central bank has frozen Tribunal payment orders. Parallel claims of legitimacy now run through court, police, presidency and prosecutors.

Sources: UnHerd, Brussels Signal.

European Commission proposes €45 billion Ukraine loan repayable only after Russian reparations

Ursula von der Leyen on 18 November proposed lending Ukraine up to €45 billion for 2027, with principal due only after Russia pays war reparations. The sum would cover about two-thirds of a Commission-estimated €70 billion gap; partners outside the bloc would be asked for the rest. Stacked on €45 billion still due in 2027 under the December 2025 €90 billion loan, EU funding could reach €90 billion in a single year. Up to €25 billion would be military aid, €20 billion budget support, conditional on reforms. Money would be raised on capital markets, backed by the EU budget, rolled over until reparations arrive; Brussels reserved the right to use immobilised Russian assets. Leaders are due to take it up on 26 November.

Von der Leyen said she was confident all 27 would agree and called the loan “the best way to give Ukraine a strong hand at the negotiation table.” Four governments have already said they will stay out: Slovakia, Czechia, Hungary and Bulgaria. The first three already have exemptions from guaranteeing the existing loan. Robert Fico accused Friedrich Merz of blackmail after Berlin tied the 2028–2034 EU budget to Ukraine funding. Bulgaria cites its deficit but says it will not block a joint decision. Defence Commissioner Andrius Kubilius said Russia may field some 20 million drones in 2027 and that interceptor shortages remain “serious.”

The open question is political, not technical. The Commission wants common-budget burden-sharing while several capitals refuse further cash and the EU is still outside US-led talks with Moscow. A loan that is, in practice, repaid only if Russia pays, or from frozen assets Belgium has blocked, is a fiscal claim on the Union whether or not it is labelled a grant.

Sources: Brussels Signal.

Leave a Comment