Analysis: Europe — 12 November 2026
European Commission drops bid to class hate speech as an EU crime
The European Commission has abandoned a five-year effort to add hate speech and hate crime to the list of EU crimes. The withdrawal is listed in an annex to the 2027 work programme adopted on 4 November, among files to be dropped within six months. Officials said Council work on the proposal had stopped. In its place Brussels is considering a directive on online “incitement to violence and hatred,” which could pass by qualified majority. The same window brought a national case: Michel Houellebecq was indicted in France over a 2022 Front Populaire interview in which he criticised Muslims and called the “Great Replacement” a “statistical fact.” He faces up to one year in prison and a €45,000 fine.
Ursula von der Leyen floated the EU listing in 2020; the formal proposal was tabled on 9 December 2021. Extending Article 83(1) TFEU required unanimity in the Council. MEPs urged action in January 2024, but capitals never agreed. A 2008 framework decision already obliges states to criminalise public incitement to violence or hatred on racial and religious grounds. The replacement would use existing computer-crime powers. Houellebecq is charged under the 1972 Pleven Law after complaints by Muslim and left-wing anti-racist groups. He was acquitted in 2002 for remarks about Islam as a creed; speaking of “Muslims” this time weakens that line of defence.
Free-speech groups welcomed the withdrawal but treat the QMV route as a workaround. ADF International’s Adina Portaru said national hate-speech laws already prosecute peaceful expression. Scholars Jacob Mchangama and Natalie Alkiviadou argued that pursuing similar aims through digital-crime competences “warrants scrutiny.” UnHerd’s Nathan Pinkoski reads the Houellebecq indictment as lawfare that deters publishers from airing sceptical views. The Digital Services Act remains in force. Whether Brussels has retreated or merely changed legal vehicles is still open.
Sources: Brussels Signal, UnHerd.
Warsaw Independence March hits 250,000 after Tusk tribunal takeover
City authorities put Warsaw’s 11 November Independence March at about 250,000 people, 150 per cent above last year; organisers claimed 500,000. President Karol Nawrocki led the column. PiS, Konfederacja, Grzegorz Braun’s KKP and Mateusz Morawiecki’s Rozwój Plus were present. The turnout followed the 30 October move by Tusk-aligned judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, who suspended Tribunal president Bogdan Święczkowski and deputy Bartłomiej Sochański, with police at the court. Poland’s Supreme Court overturned those suspensions on Tuesday. Święczkowski said he would try to re-enter the building on Thursday. Tusk marked the day in Szczecin and accused Nawrocki of dividing Poles.
The dual executive has been deadlocked since Nawrocki’s 2025 election. The president has vetoed dozens of bills and blocked judicial and ambassadorial appointments. The Tribunal’s 2021 finding that parts of the EU treaties conflict with the Polish constitution still shapes who interprets the law. Von der Leyen skipped a joint press appearance with Nawrocki at a Visegrád summit. A Tusk-aligned assembly on 17 November is due to consider stripping Święczkowski’s immunity and authorising detention.
Jarosław Kaczyński floated a single right-wing list for the 2027 Sejm; Sławomir Mentzen posed with a “Reset” banner striking out both Tusk and Kaczyński. Brussels Report’s Johannes Vervloed frames the clash as sovereignists versus federalists, including over the zloty and gold reserves. Earlier polls found the largest share of Poles backing neither camp. Whether the march hardens into an electoral front, and whether two rival courts can coexist, remains unresolved.
Sources: Hungarian Conservative, The Brussels Report.